May 11, 2026

Pullman, 1894: How the Federal Government Learned to Break a Strike

The Pullman Strike of 1894 taught the federal government two things it never forgot. A court injunction plus the Sherman Antitrust Act could break any strike by paper, without firing a shot. And a union that drew a color line handed the bosses a strikebreaking force for free. Every labor injunction since runs on the same chassis.

George Pullman built a town and called it a gift to his workers. He owned every house in it. He owned the stores they shopped in. His workers rented from him and bought from him. When the depression of 1893 hit, he cut wages at the Pullman Palace Car Company by about 25 percent. He did not cut the rent on a single house. Families in the "model town" could not feed their children.

On May 11, 1894, they walked out.

The boycott

The American Railway Union was new. Eugene V. Debs, its president, had built it the year before as an industrial union for every rail worker, not one craft at a time. At the ARU's Chicago convention on June 22, 1894, the delegates voted to back the Pullman workers with a national boycott. ARU members would refuse to handle any train carrying a Pullman car. Within a week, rail traffic west of Chicago was paralyzed.

The railroads had already organized themselves into the General Managers' Association, a cartel of the major lines running into Chicago. They coordinated the response. They did not need to break the strike on the tracks. They broke it in federal court.

The injunction

On July 2, 1894, a federal circuit court in Chicago, Judges Peter S. Grosscup and William A. Woods presiding, issued an injunction drafted at the request of Attorney General Richard Olney and his special counsel Edwin Walker. Olney had represented railroads before he took the job of Attorney General. The injunction invoked the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890, a law passed to break up corporate trusts, and turned it on the union instead. The boycott was recast as an illegal conspiracy in restraint of interstate commerce and the mails. The order was so broad that Debs could not legally send a telegram, a letter, or a public statement directing his own members.

A union that cannot communicate with its members is not a union. That was the point.

The next night, July 3, 1894, President Grover Cleveland ordered federal troops into Chicago. Illinois Governor John Peter Altgeld telegrammed Cleveland in protest on July 5, 1894. The state had ample force of its own. The federal troops were "unnecessary" and "unjustifiable." Soldiers "not under the civil authorities" had no business on Illinois soil. Cleveland ignored him. About 30 people were killed in Chicago before the strike was crushed by late July 1894.

Debs was convicted of contempt on December 14, 1894 and sentenced to six months. On May 27, 1895, a unanimous Supreme Court upheld the injunction in In re Debs, 158 U.S. 564. Justice David J. Brewer wrote that the federal government had the power to go into court and shut down a strike whenever it touched interstate commerce or the mails, which after 1895 meant any strike of any size.

The labor injunction became the employer class's default weapon for the next 37 years, until the Norris-LaGuardia Act of 1932 finally restricted it. Every rail strike, textile strike, and miner's strike in that span was broken or bloodied by a piece of paper signed by a federal judge.

The color line

The ARU did this to itself, too. At its 1894 convention, a motion to admit Black workers failed, 113 to 102. The union's constitution restricted membership to white workers. The Pullman Company employed roughly 2,000 Black porters, shut out of the ARU by that vote. When the boycott came, the porters, with no union to honor, kept the Pullman cars moving. The bosses did not have to recruit a strikebreaking force. The ARU had built one for them.

Debs lived with that failure. His later socialist writings, after 1897, are consistently anti-racist in principle. By then the ARU was already broken. An industrial union that draws a color line has already lost the fight. The CIO would learn it 40 years later. The AFL would keep refusing the lesson for most of the twentieth century.

The template

Six days after Cleveland sent the Army to Chicago, the Labor Day bill he had signed on June 28, 1894 became the official federal holiday for American workers. We wrote about that last week. The timing was not an accident.

The injunction is the longer shadow. Every modern federal restraining order against a strike, every Taft-Hartley injunction since 1947, every National Labor Relations Board petition for equitable relief, runs on the chassis built in the summer of 1894. And every organizing drive where the boss splits workers by race, by citizenship, by contractor status, or by craft is running the same play the Pullman Company ran when the ARU handed it the porters.

The bosses learned Pullman. The workers had to learn it twice.

Sources

← All weekly posts